The inclusionary, exclusionary Ode to Joy

We don't really talk about "surfing the web", particularly now we're supposed to be getting our stuff from algorithmically optimised apps, but I much prefer the sentiment of just following your nose and stumbling upon things you wouldn't otherwise have considered. Digital Flaneurism, as my old chum Jon B used to call it.

So I'm surfing around and come across this, from a local character.

Ode To Joy as the anthem of the European Union is a fascinating thing because it's not exclusive, being extracted from Beethoven's 9th. Repurposed, if you will, like Blake's And did those feet was repurposed by Hubert Parry to bolster support for WW1 and in turn become the preferred national anthem for those who find God Save The King/Queen a turgid dirge.

I was reminded of something I'd seen where some brainy chap had pointed out the ideological flexibility of Ode to Joy, how it had been adopted by nazis, communists, racists, revolutionaries and now the EU. It was, of course, Slavoj Žižek in his highly recommended 2012 film The Pervert's Guide to Ideology in which he uses scenes from classic films to illustrate philosophical ideas, in this case A Clockwork Orange, in which the music of ol' Ludwig Van plays a major role.

The interesting thing Žižek points out is that all the ideologies that use Ode to Joy only seem to use the first bit, the rousing, sublime, brotherhood-of-man stuff which lends itself to national myths. But this is followed by a second bit (starting here), a more carnivalesque, vulgar, common bit, evoking the kind of people who might be excluded by from the brotherhood of man, because as we know from history, anything that binds people together requires other people to be cast aside.

End-note: The EU has a collection of versions of Ode to Joy for use in films and the like. They range from the sublime to the laughably awful.

Up next Oak Apple Orchestra at If Wet, 2014 Sunday Reads
Latest posts Update your Feed Reader! This blog has been mothballed. Revising the 1972 Project Starmer has effectively introduced a Twitter policy We desperately need social media literacy or the fascists will win History is constantly being “erased”, and that’s OK. Last week a jigsaw saved my life Lost in Bluster Insomnia Journal 07 May 20 Stirchley Safari Whales on the Hudson Closing the Covid browser tabs Solving (a bit of) the Coronavirus from home Stopping A proposal to support independent businesses that cannot survive social distancing A modest proposal for slowing down cars Cross City Walks - the movie Good composition is ideologically fraught Short Reviews of Films Understanding Gilliam, and other men of a certain age Grace Lee’s talk: Diary, Discourse and Demonetisation Star Wars is Over (in a good way) Election notes How to read articles on websites that don’t want you to read their articles Uranium Club RIP Tom Spurgeon Introducing Notes, my new microblog Lindelof’s Watchmen, and the creative employment of corporate IP Eisenhower and the Hippies The Widelux, as used by Jeff Bridges Media with Edges Art-trip to Liverpool